Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Laura Jedeed's avatar

Audio is up!

@Matt Taibbi you’d probably hate this article quite a bit but you might like the ending, consider reading it and telling me why I’m wrong (I am aware he will never see this, yes)

Expand full comment
Ornithomancer's avatar

Excellent article. It makes me want to think and comment but I need time to digest it before really getting into it.

Taibbi is weird and sad and infuriating. I subscribed to him when he first started on substack. I read his serialized first draft of Hate Inc and it legitimately changed, on a fundamental level, the way I consume media to this day, I would like to think for the better. His analogy of big media being essentially cigarette breaks makes intrinsic sense to me. If I had to pick between him and Greenwald for "journalist I used to respect but turned heel", I think I'd probably pick Taibbi.

I didn't dig a lot into the Twitter files but Taibbi was so rabid to tear into them that he left a *lot* of factual errors behind him from other peoples' critique and left a lot of things that feel ethically questionable to me in them, including personal details. It bothered me he was so pumped to work the story he never stopped for a moment to wonder if he was getting curated views of Twitter or everything, unvarnished. Like you said, he never questioned the reasons *why* Musk has done what he has done. He didn't want to dry up the spigot of what he probably thought was career-defining.

I've said elsewhere that Musk loves making the grand, over the top bonkers gesture, and I can see how that could be catnip to someone like Taibbi. It's surprising and sobering to me to watch him walk into the mouth of the beast with a grin on his face and barely a second thought.

Expand full comment
23 more comments...

No posts